Best BMW 3 Series Engines: N47, B47, B48 and B58 Ranked

The best BMW 3 Series engine to buy is the B58B30 (76/100) if you want petrol performance, or the B47D20A (64/100) if you're a diesel buyer. The N47D20C (56/100) in an E90 is a scrap-risk — a £4,350 recon cost on a car worth £2,500 doesn't make financial sense.
This ranking covers the three most-enquired 3 Series diesel and petrol engines across the E90, F30 and G20 generations, based on 826 verified UK enquiries (256 for E90, 380 for F30, 190 for G20) from our 2025 dataset. We've scored each engine across five dimensions — reliability, repair cost, repairability, parts supply and replacement economics — to give you a clear, data-backed answer before you buy.
The Short Answer
Best overall: petrol: B58B30 (76/100) — found in the G20 340i, M340i and later F30 340i. Strong reliability, predictable repair costs and excellent replacement economics.
Best diesel: B47D20A (64/100) — fitted to the F30 320d and G20 320d. Front-mounted chain, fewer failure patterns than the N47 and lower recon cost.
Avoid the N47 on an E90: The N47D20C (56/100) with a rear-mounted timing chain is a known failure point. Recon cost (£4,350) can exceed the car's value (£2,500). A £650 chain becomes a £2,500 job because the engine has to come out.
The N47 is better on an F30: The same engine in a later F30 has different economics. A £4,350 recon on a £4,500–£14,000 car can still make sense on higher-value examples.
The B58 isn't available on every generation: It appears in the F30 LCI (2015–2019) as the 340i, and in the G20 (2019–present) as the M340i and 340i. Earlier 335i models use the N55, which isn't covered here.
How We Ranked the Engines
We score each engine across five dimensions, each weighted 0–20. The total score is out of 100.
Reliability (0–20): How often this engine appears in our failure pattern data and specialist reports. A higher score means fewer known catastrophic issues.
Repair Cost (0–20): The typical cost to recon the engine using independent specialist supply-and-fit prices. Lower costs score higher.
Repairability (0–20): How accessible the engine is for repair work. An engine with a rear-mounted timing chain scores lower than one with a front-mounted chain.
Parts Supply (0–20): Whether reconditioned and used units are readily available across the UK. All three score well here.
Replacement Economics (0–20): The cost of the recon engine relative to the typical value of the car it's fitted to. If a recon costs more than the car's worth, it scores poorly.
BMW 3 Series Engines Ranked
Rank | Engine | Score | Request Volume (2025) | Recon Cost (Supply Only) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | B58B30 | 76/100 | 540 enquiries | £3,800–£6,000 | The petrol sweet spot: strong, repairable and fitted to high-value G20 and F30 LCI cars. |
2 | B47D20A | 64/100 | 930 enquiries | £2,800–£4,500 | The best diesel option. Front-mounted chain, robust design and good economics on F30/G20 hosts. |
3 | N47D20C | 56/100 | 1,450 enquiries | £3,200–£5,500 | High-risk on E90; a workhorse on F30. Check chain history before buying. |
Score Breakdown
Rank 1: B58B30 — 76/100
Dimension | Score | How It Was Determined |
|---|---|---|
Reliability (0–20) | 16 | ★ B-series petrol: well-understood cooling system and PCV issues, no catastrophic failure pattern |
Repair Cost (0–20) | 12 | Recon midpoint £4,900 (independent supply only) |
Repairability (0–20) | 12 | Standard modern layout; good access for most repairs |
Parts Supply (0–20) | 16 | Well-supported across UK specialists |
Replacement Economics (0–20) | 20 | £4,900 recon on an £18,000 G20 = 27% of car's value — excellent |
TOTAL | 76/100 | Evidence confidence: High — 540 verified enquiries with robust failure pattern data. The B58 is the most-enquired petrol engine across all BMW models in our dataset. |
Rank 2: B47D20A — 64/100
Dimension | Score | How It Was Determined |
|---|---|---|
Reliability (0–20) | 16 | ★ B47 4.0: EGR cooler failure is the main pattern; timing chain far less frequent than N47 |
Repair Cost (0–20) | 16 | Recon midpoint £3,650 — the cheapest of the three |
Repairability (0–20) | 12 | Front-mounted chain; standard modern layout |
Parts Supply (0–20) | 16 | Well-supported across UK specialists |
Replacement Economics (0–20) | 4 | £3,650 recon on a £4,500 F30 = 81% of car's value — borderline |
TOTAL | 64/100 | Evidence confidence: High — 930 verified enquiries. The B47 is the most-enquired 3 Series engine in our dataset (380 F30 + 190 G20 = 570 combined), reflecting its popularity rather than poor reliability. |
Rank 3: N47D20C — 56/100
Dimension | Score | How It Was Determined |
|---|---|---|
Reliability (0–20) | 12 | ★ N47 3.0: rear timing chain is a known failure point at 60k–120k miles |
Repair Cost (0–20) | 16 | Recon midpoint £4,350 — slightly higher than B47 |
Repairability (0–20) | 8 | Rear chain means engine-out labour — significantly more difficult |
Parts Supply (0–20) | 16 | Well-supported — it's the most-enquired engine in our entire dataset |
Replacement Economics (0–20) | 4 | £4,350 recon on a £2,500 E90 = 174% of car's value — scrap-risk |
TOTAL | 56/100 | Evidence confidence: High — 1,450 verified enquiries across all BMW models, including 256 in the E90 and a further 380 in the F30. The N47 is the most common engine we're asked about. |
Why This Ranking Might Differ For You
High-mileage buyers (100k+ miles)
If you're buying a 3 Series with over 100,000 miles, the B58 becomes even more attractive — its known issues (coolant leaks, PCV valve) are relatively inexpensive to fix. The B47 is also a strong choice. The N47, however, is approaching its failure window; factor in a timing chain inspection before purchase.
Short-term ownership (under 2 years)
If you only need the car for 18–24 months, the N47 on a cheap E90 can still make sense — provided the chain has been done or you're prepared to scrap it if it fails. The B58 is overkill for a short-term runabout.
Towing

The B47 diesel has better low-end torque for towing than the B58. Factor in the EGR cooler recall status before committing — if it's been done, the B47 is a solid tow car.
Budget buyers (£4,000–£7,000)
In this price bracket, you're looking at E90 or early F30 N47 cars. You're gambling on timing chain history. A car with documented chain replacement is worth a premium. Without it, you're buying a potential £4,350 bill.
Methodology & Limitations
This ranking is based on 24,650 UK enquiries from our internal CRM data across 62 engines and 300+ models, covering January–December 2025. We combine this with specialist interviews and publicly available failure pattern data.
Important: Enquiry count measures demand for a replacement engine, not the probability that the engine fails. The N47 has the highest request volume (1,450) because it's one of the most common BMW engines on UK roads, not necessarily because it's the least reliable. The B58 has lower request volume (540) partly because there are far fewer B58 cars on the road than N47 cars.
Vehicle values are based on typical UK trade values from Auto Trader and other market data (2025). Recon costs are supply-only independent specialist rates — main dealer costs may be 30–50% higher.
Our Engine Score is an editorial assessment built from proprietary enquiry data and our vetted specialist network. It is not a customer review score.
Known Failure Patterns in Scope
N47D20C — Timing chain stretch and tensioner failure
Typical mileage: 60k–120k
Chain replacement: £650–£1,800; full engine: £2,500–£6,500
Early warning: cold-start rattle from the rear of the engine. Catastrophic if ignored.
B47D20A — EGR cooler failure
Typical mileage: 60k–120k
EGR cooler replacement: £600–£1,200
BMW recall issued. Check if it's been done before buying.
B58B30 — Coolant leaks (expansion tank, water pump), PCV valve failure
Typical mileage: 60k–120k
Water pump: £500–£1,000; PCV: £400–£800
Well-understood issues; relatively inexpensive repairs compared to N47 chain work.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is the N47 really that bad?
It depends on which generation you're looking at. In an E90, the N47 is a scrap-risk because a £4,350 recon engine can cost more than the car's £2,500 value. In an F30, the same engine can make sense because the car is worth more. The key question isn't "is it reliable?" — it's "has the timing chain been done?"
2. Which 3 Series engine is the most reliable?
Based on our data, the B58B30 is the most reliable petrol option and the B47D20A is the most reliable diesel. Both have well-understood failure patterns that are non-catastrophic, unlike the N47's timing chain issue.
3. Is the B58 better than the N55?
The B58 is a significant step forward from the N55. It has an improved closed-deck design, better cooling and fewer known failure points. The N55 is still a good engine, but the B58 is more robust and has better parts support in the recon market.
4. Is the B47 more reliable than the N47?
Yes. The B47's front-mounted timing chain means it doesn't require engine-out labour for chain replacement — a £650 chain job stays a £650 job. The B47 also has fewer documented failure patterns than the N47.
5. Which 3 Series engine should I avoid?
The N47 in an E90 (2005–2012) is the one to avoid unless the timing chain has been done recently. If you're buying an F30 with the N47, prioritise cars with documented chain history. The B58 and B47 are both safer choices.
6. What's the cost to replace a B58 engine?
A reconditioned B58 engine typically costs £3,800–£6,000 supply-only, with fitting adding £650–£910 in independent labour (10–14 hours at £65/hr). On a G20 worth £18,000–£35,000, that's 27% of the car's value — manageable economics compared to the N47.
The Verdict
If you want a petrol 3 Series, buy the B58B30 — it's the best-engineered engine in this comparison, with manageable repair costs and good economics on G20 and later F30 cars. If you want a diesel, buy the B47D20A — it's more reliable than the N47 and the recon cost is lower.
The N47 is a gamble. On an E90, it's a bad one. On an F30, it's a calculated risk — buy only with documented timing chain history.
Based on UK enquiry data from January–December 2025. Vehicle values are typical UK trade values per 2025 market data.
Need a Replacement BMW Engine?
Get an instant quote for reconditioned or tested low-mileage BMW engines with full warranty coverage.